Fiction-l and genres
The last couple of days on fiction-l have been extremely interesting. There has been much thoughtful and interesting dicusssion on genre and interfiling or separating by genre. Barry asked late on Friday for some research in this area, here's what I replied withQuoting Barry Trott
"I have not had a chance to go
back to the literature yet on this topic, but if anyone knows of any
quantitative studies that look at the impact of either interfiling or
genre separation on things like patron satisfaction and circulation rates,
I would love to hear about them."
Barry asked for research on what I like to call Genrefication. Here's
my list of interesting and informative research articles in no
particular order, with comments. I may have missed a few in the last
year.
Sharon Baker and Karen L Wallace, The Responsive Public Library: How
to develop and market a winning collection. Libraries Unlimited, 2nd
edition 2002.
This is a whole book that I really like. Since Sharon is an expert in
this area (as you'll see from the number of citations she has below)
and this is her major book, this is pretty much the best place to look
for information on genres, browsing and selection. One chapter that
was certainly in the previous edition (and should in this one, but I
dont have it with me to verify) was an excellent one, "Will patrons be
helped or hindered by an integrated collection?"
Margaret Speak, A survey of reading patterns of elderly people using
the Age Concern Centre Library, Leicester, Health Libraries Review,
vol 7, no I, 1990:8-13. An interesting study from the UK.
Sharon L Baker, Will Fiction Classification schemes increase use? RQ,
vol 27, no 3, 1988: 366-376
S. Baker, Overload, Browsers and Selection, Library and Information
Science Research, vol 8, Oct 1986: 315-29
Baker, Sharon L. and Gay W. Shepherd, Fiction classifiction schemes:
the principles behind them and their successes, RQ vol 27, Winter
1987: 245-51
Shepherd, Gay W. and Sharon L. Baker, Fiction classification, a brief
review of the research, Public Libraries, vol 26, spring 1987: 31-32
one of the easiest to read versions
Baker, The display phenomenon: an exploration into the factors causing
the increased circulation of displayed books, Library quarterly, vol
56, 1986: 237-57
L. Yu and A. O'Brian. Domain of Adult fiction librarianship, in
Advances in Librarianship, vol 20, 1996:151-90.
Yu and O'Brian's review article is very good, though long and not
always easy to get a copy of. Their section on selection and browsing
I remember as particularly good and I liked that they included a lot
of research from outside the US.
Baker, A Decade's Worth of Research on browsing fiction collections,
in guiding the reader to the next book, ed by Ken Shearer, Neal
Schuman (Lu?) 1996: 127-47
The best and I think one of the most recent overviews of her work and
that on patron browsing and selection, which of course is very
affected by genre distinctions
Cannell, Jeffrey and McClusky, Eileen T, Genrefication: fiction
classification and increased circulation (at Cumberland County Public
Library and Information Center, Clifford branch), in guiding the
reader to the next book, 1996: 159-68
Harrell, Gail, Use of fiction categories in major American libraries,
in guiding the reader to the next book, 1996: 149-57
Saarti, James, Feeding with the spoon, or the effects of shelf
classification of fiction on the loaning of fiction, Information
Services and Use, vol 17, nos 2/3, 1997:159-69
I do love the title of this article....
Richard, Amy J. Genre fiction classification: a study of the Durham
County Library, UNC master's paper.
this thesis reports results from a public library before and after a
classification project.
It can be found online through UNC's SLIS online thesis depository, I
have the pdf I downloaded a couple of years ago if anyone is
interested
Amy Funderburk, Romance Collections in NOrth Carolina Public Libraries
: are all genres treated equally?, UNC Master's paper. Online at:
http://etd.ils.unc.edu/dspace/handle/1901/44
Since romance may be one of the most commonly separated genres I
wanted to inlcude this recent paper
Everything should be correct in the citations, though not in the best
MLA order. Let me know if anyone needs any more details on any of
these.
My lit review in last summer's RUSQ also had a section selection,
browsing and genres, and most of the references were from that
project. Here's the reference for the lit review.
Moyer, Jessica E. "Adult fiction reading: A Literature Review of
Readers' Advisory Services, Adult Fiction Librarianship, and Fiction
Readers" RUSQ vol 44, no 3, 2005.
Happy reading
2/15 Updated Author/Chapter List
As of 2/15 the author/chapter list is as follows:
Part I: What do we know about readers’ advisory services and what do we know about our readers?
Chapter 1 – Readers advisory services – what we know about what we do - Author: Barry Trott
Chapter 2 – Who are our readers? And what do we know about them? (research references Ross: Reading Matters, Moyer: CAS paper, incidental information acquisition and learning, Williamson and Ross) – Author: David Wright? or Jane?
Chapter 3 – The international perspective – Europe, UK and Aus/NZ – Author?
Part II: – Different forms of readers’ advisory
Chapter 4 – Nonfiction – Sarah Statz Cords (LU article and book)
Chapter 5 – Audiovisual – Author: Joyce Saricks
Chapter 6 –Young Adults – Author: Heather Booth
Chapter 7 - Children – Heather is talking to the Downer’s Grove children’s librarians who are very interested
Chapter 8 – Bookgroups - Research Bessman-Taylor dissertation – Authors: Joan Bessman for research section, Andrew Smith for librarian
Chapter 9 – Working with Romance and other Genre Readers – Research references: Radway, Cathie Linz - Author: Katie Dunneback
Part III: How to do it
Chapter 10 – RA Interview: In person and Online (Research references: Saricks, Smith) –
Chapter 11 – Readers’ advisory tools Author: Mary Towner
Chapter 12 – Continuing Education author: ?
Chapter 13 – Genrefication, classification, cataloguing and shelving – Nanette Wargo Donohue
Chapter 14 – Marketing Author? Jane?
Chapter 15 – Collection development: Author: Cynthia Orr
Part IV: Conclusion
Chapter 16: Future of RA - Author: Andrew Smith and Jessica Moyer
Chapter 17: Why should I conduct RA research? Jessica and Barry or Connie Van Fleet
Appendix
A – Reading a research article - References: Basic Research Methods for Librarians, 4th ed. – Author: Jessica
B – Research methodologies – the good and the bad – References: Basic Research Methods for Librarians – Author: Jessica Moyer and Terry Weech